KITCHEN TIPS & TECHNIQUES
and special offer emails.
|
KITCHEN TIPS & TECHNIQUES
Apple Buyer's Guide

How to choose the best apples for cooking and eating
The best apple pie filling combines “saucy” apples (that cook down to a saucelike texture) and “shapely” apples (that hold their shape after baking). Pick one variety from each category. SAUCY: McIntosh, Cortland, Macoun, Mutsu (Crispin), Paula Red or Empire. SHAPELY: Granny Smith, Golden Delicious, Jonathon, Jonagold, Northern Spy or Ida Red.
A Guide to Common Apple Varieties

|
 |
Braeburn: Braeburns have muted greenish-gold to red skin and pale yellow flesh. Fragrant and smooth, these medium-to-large fruits have a well-balanced flavor—sweet with just a hint of tartness.
|
 |
 |
Cortland: If you want to include fresh apples in a dish but don’t have time to assemble it á la minute, Cortlands are the best bet—they don’t turn brown as quickly as other varieties and the bright red skin and snow-white flesh look striking against a contrasting backdrop. Juicy and mildly tart, this apple softens nicely when cooked, making it as well suited for baking as it is for salad.
|
 |
 |
Crispin (see Mutsu)
|
 |
 |
Empire: The delightful child of the McIntosh and Red Delicious varieties retains the sweet-tart flavor of the Mac with a crisper bite and creamier flesh. This shiny red apple with a hint of green is perfect for baking and freezing, but can be eaten out-of-hand just as well. Smaller fruits are perfect for packing in lunchboxes.
|
 |
 |
Fuji: A relative newcomer to the American public, these baseball-sized beauties have become hugely popular due to their sweet flavor and incredibly crispy texture.
|
 |
 |
Gala (or Royal Gala): One of the earliest available varieties, the Gala apple takes its sweet, succulent nature from two Delicious cultivars (Golden and Kidd’s Orange Red). Its thin skin and tender, pale yellow flesh makes it a great out-of-hand eating apple or sauce ingredient.
|
 |
 |
Golden Delicious: This golden orb has creamy, firm yellow flesh and lightly speckled skin. The flavor is absolutely sweet and mellow, making it a versatile cooking apple. It holds its shape well when baked, but take care when storing and handling—the skin bruises easily.
|
 |
 |
Granny Smith: Lime-green speckled skin that resists bruising and very firm, crisp flesh characterize this popular apple. Its sharp, tart flavor holds up well in recipes with spicy notes, and the flesh is firm enough to retain its shape when cooked.
|
 |
 |
Honeycrisp: What’s in a name? This one says it all. This apple has exceptionally crisp, juicy, sweet-as-honey flesh with just a hint of tartness that makes it a tasty treat any time of the day. You can also use this apple for baking (if you can resist eating them all!). Pale yellow flesh is surrounded by mottled red-and-gold skin.
|
 |
 |
Idared: This rosy, brightly colored apple is a cross between two New York cultivars, Jonathan and Wagener. The firm, tart flesh ranges from yellowish-green to faintly pink, and holds its shape well during baking. With its well-developed aromatics, this fruit contributes a strong apple flavor. Cook with the skin on and then strain to make a beautiful pink applesauce.
|
 |
 |
Jonagold: A cross between Jonathan and Golden Delicious, this bumpy, stripy fruit isn’t super fragrant but tends to rank very high in taste tests. The skin is gold with orange-blush stripes, surrounding a creamy, pale yellow flesh with a juicy, crisp texture that shares the shape-holding characteristics of its parents. This fruit is sweet with a nice balance of tart.
|
 |
 |
Jonathan: Sporting a bright, sweetly tart flavor, this red-striped greenish-yellow fruit boasts a smooth, tough skin and firm flesh that retains its shape well during cooking. This New York native apple doesn’t store as well as other varieties, so use it within a few weeks of purchasing.
|
 |
 |
Macoun: A crossbreed of the McIntosh and Jersey Black cultivars, the Macoun apple is regarded as one of the best all-purpose cooking apples around. This dark red fruit with creamy white flesh is soft, tender and perfect for sauce. It has a sweet, rich apple flavor with hints of berry.
|
 |
 |
McIntosh: This apple has been loved since John McIntosh discovered seedlings in Ontario in 1811. The tender white flesh is crisp when freshly harvested, but soon adopts a softer consistency, making it perfect for cooking into pies or sauce. Macs are sweet and juicy with a pleasant tanginess.
|
 |
 |
Mutsu: The Mutsu apple, also called Crispin, is a large, yellowish-green fruit with an orange blush and juicy, tender-crisp, coarse-grained flesh. This cross between Golden Delicious and the Japanese Indo has a complex, spicy-sweet flavor reminiscent of anise and is great for eating or baking.
|
 |
 |
Northern Spy: This red-, gold- and green-striped apple has a limited availability in the U.S.—while growing, the fruit is fragile and susceptible to several common afflictions. A Northern Spy tree may take up to 14 years to bear fruit, so it is frequently grafted onto other apple trees to encourage growth. It’s worth the wait, though—this apple is tart and juicy-crisp, with finely textured flesh that holds its shape well, perfect for pie and other baking uses.
|
 |
 |
Paula Red: This early-ripening variation of the McIntosh is soft and nicely balanced between sweet and tart, cooking down perfectly into sauces. Its dusty red skin with gold and tan spots yields to tender, slightly mealy white flesh with a flavor evocative of strawberries.
|
Photos: Honeycrisp, Macoun, Mutsu, Paula Red: Courtesy New York Apple Association; Northern Spy: Courtesy Michigan Apple Committee. All other apples: Ken Burris, EatingWell

Related Recipes
Healthy Apple Recipes and Cooking Tips
Stay current with the latest issue of EatingWell. Subscribe Risk-Free Now!
| USER COMMENTS — Add Your Comment |
I like the FUJI apples the best and for making pies Granny Smith wins me over.
R. Hamilton, KC, MO |
Thank You for this helpful information.
Jeanette Martin, Bronx, NY |
I agree with Lara (Texas), Pink Lady is also my favorite. It is a great storing apple. The last apple variety picked in late Oct./early Nov., I get mine at the end of December(when the orchard I work at closes for the season). Stored in the bottom drawer of my refrigerator, they are still crisp and juicy in March!! Another great early variety is the Ginger Gold. Thanks for the other apple info!
Suzanne Kaluszka, Lebanon, CT |
Thanks for the guide to shapely vs. saucy!
I also love the Ginger Gold, as Suzanne stated below! :)
Susanne Johnson, Downers Grove, IL |
What about the Pink Lady? It is my all time favorite apple for eating out-of-hand!
Lara Lleverino, Fort Worth, TX |
I prefer to find unique heirloom varieties at a farmstand or orchard. Yet my favorite easily available Autumn apple is the Macoun. It is so superb that almost everyone I know is willing to pay extra for it when it is available. For year round use, the Granny Smith wins my vote.
Kimberly Antal, Longmeadow, MA |
Great great mag. In my old age 80 plus, I'm learning to cook. I have a great apple tree.
Morris Brown, Lompoc, CA |
I agree about Granny Smith apples being great for pies. What about the Winesap for your list?
Sue Owen, Falls Church, VA |
I LOVE this!! My grocery used to have this posted with each type of apple but quit doing this. I have wondered about many of these forever!!! Thanks so much.
Carol Adams, Indianapolis, IN |
I love the Honey Crisp, however I like to use a mix of apple types when I am cooking to get a well-rounded flavor. We usually pick at least 4 different kinds... Empire, Macoun, Honey Crisp, and Burgandy.
Jean Parker, Oswego, NY |
We are lucky here to have the northern spy. Best pie apples there is I have won pie contest with these apples. The only kind I bake pies with.
Bonnie Spires, Mancelona, MI |
Hi, My favorite apples are the Grimes Golden & a summer transparent,that we call the June apple. The Grimes Golden is a "Fall" apple,comes in late September,or early October. They're so popular,it's kind of like "now you see 'em,now you don't". They have a skin like the Golden Delicious,& if memory serves me right,they're not as big as the Golden Delicious. I haven't had any Grimes Golden for a few years. Both the Grimes Golden & the June apples makes good pies,apple butter,AND fried apples. Yum! Oh! The skin of the June apple is a light green to start off with,then as they ripen,is a yellowish white. They usually comes in every other year.
Lynda L. Scaggs, Christiansburg, VA |
A hearty second to the lady from Christiansburg! My grandparents in Front Royal, VA had a June yellow transparent apple tree, and it spoiled me for life w/ its applesauce and fried apples. I love a full flavor, sweet-tart, firm, juicy apple. Does anyone know a source for the Junes that isn't in someone's back yard? Macouns are wonderful, but I've rarely found them this far south. Any sources on those?
Christy C., Richmond, VA |
I love fujis and sweet tender romes. Honercrisp is this years wonderful discovery. I needed this basic guide to goodness. Thank you.
Linda Sanders, Sallisaw, OK |
Honey crisp is the best. Hard to get year round here in WI. Fugi is next.
Barb, Racine, WI |
I like Fuji apples far, they are very crisp and the texture does not change with prolonged storage as some other varieties.
Jeannie, Buffalo, NY |
« Back
|
|